Meanwhile…
Nina carefully sliced the cake, unable to stop herself from glancing at Penny across the counter. Penny watched the cake like a hawk, looking as if she might drool if Nina stalled any longer.
Quickly, Nina placed a slice on a plate and slid it in front of Penny.
"Here," she said. "Eat this first while I get the guys some."
"Huh?" Penny snapped her eyes up, blinking innocently.
"Finn and I don't really eat sweets that much, so this cake will just sit in the fridge forever." Nina chuckled, winking. "We'd really appreciate it if you helped us finish it."
Penny's eyes lit up, her mouth stretching into a wide grin. "Sweet! I might start living here to help you with the leftovers. Thanks!"
